Hydrogen and Oxygen Isotopes in Plants: abiotic and biotic fractionation processes

 

 

Introduction

Abiotic Fractionation

Biotic Fractionation

Case Studies

References

Links

Abiotic Fractionation

The isotopic ratios of plant material integrate both biotic and abiotic factors that fractionate between different isotopes based upon their atomic masses. These factors fractionate between different pools in the hydrologic cycle, which results in each pool having a unique isotopic signature (Fig. 1). Thus, knowing the isotopic signatures of different water sources can help plant physiologists determine the origin from which plant water has been derived.


Fig. 1 Using tritium 3H and d 18O to identify pools in the hydrologic cycle. Tritium, released into the atmosphere during the testing of the hydrogen bomb, is expressed in tritium units (TU) and del 18O is expressed conventionally as per mil (figure obtained from IAEA).

Tracing the Hydrologic Cycle
The relationship between the d18O and d2H in the world's fresh waters follows a predictable linear relationship (Fig 2). This predictable relationship is referred to as the "meteoric water line" (Craig, 1961) and allows for the approximation of d2H based on the measurement d18O and vice versa. However, deviations from this predictable relationship can reveal perturbations to the hydrologic cycle. Millenial variations in d18O contained in the world's oceans and the polar ice caps have been used to infer changes in past climate (Shakleton and Opdyke, 1973). Because of their different masses, isotopes have different kinetics that are exemplified during phase changes, which result in fractionation.

Fig. 2 The "meteoric water line" as calculated by Craig (1961), with warm regions characterized by more enriched (positive) values of hydrogen and oxygen isotopes and cooler regions characterized by more depleted (negative) values. Isotope ratios are reported with respect to Standard Mean Ocean Water (smow)

Evaporation
As heat is applied to liquid water, it changes to a gaseous state, and this process discriminates between different isotopes. This is conceptually intuitive, as more energy is required to lift and transport a heavier atom than a light atom. This is why salinity and d 18O are positively correlated in the world's oceans- as salinity increases so does the amount of the heavier isotope (Craig and Gordon, 1965). However, this relationship is affected by humidity, whereby water interacts with the vapor phase. If we assume that relative humidity is zero (h = 0), then the enrichment of both d 18O and d 2H, follow the exponential Rayleigh distillation function:


R=Ro f ^
(a-1)

Where, R represents the isotope ratio as a function of the fraction remaining (f), a is the equilibrium fractionation constant of evaporation and Ro represents the initial isotopic ratio. However, as atmospheric humidity approaches 100%, d 2H will become more depleted than d 18O during evaporation.

Precipitation
The fractionation imparted to water as it changes from a gaseous state to a liquid state is very similar to that of evaporation except the reverse. In order for water to condense and precipitate from an air mass, the temperature must drop. As temperature drops, the heavier isotopes are selectively precipitated from the air mass through distillation (Eq 1). This phenomenon is often referred to as the "rainout" effect (Dansgard, 1964), which describes the successive depletion of d 18O and d 2H as an air mass travels from its source and loses heavier isotopes through precipitation (Fig. 3). This effect can be enhanced by orographic effects that may cause an abrupt cooling of an air mass as it rises and thus a strong gradient in isotopic ratios.

Fig. 3 Graphical depiction of Rayleigh distillation, whereby heavier isotopes of oxygen are selectively precipitated from an air mass as temperature decreases.

Groundwater
Most plants obtain their water through their roots from the groundwater. Thus knowing the isotopic signature of groundwaters at different depths can be very informative for plant physiologists. Water found deeper in the Earth's crust tends to be older and have a more attenuated isotopic signal. This means that deep groundwater exhibits much less seasonal variability in its constituent isotopes than water at the surface. This is intuitive, as waters at depth are not subject to the same seasonal temperature variability, which induces precipitation and evaporation- two important fractionating phenomena.

Global Distributions of Isotopes
The physical processes of evaporation and condensation impart isotopic signatures to water as it circulates through the hydrologic cycle. Understanding these basic physical principles allows us to make basic predictions about the isotopic signatures of waters of certain regions of the globe. For instance, as we increase in altitude and the temperature decreases, the isotopic signature of source water will become depleted (more negative). An increase in latitude will also cause a depletion in the isotopic ratio of source water due to decreased insolation and colder temperature towards the poles. These processes in conjunction with localized meteorological phenomena ultimately determine isotopic signatures of source waters available to plants (Fig.4).

Fig 4. Distribution of del 18 O in global precipitation (obtained from IAEA)

 

 

 

Ashley Ballantyne
Ashley.Ballantyne@duke.edu
Duke University
Earth and Ocean Sciences
324Old Chemistry
Box 90229
Durham, NC 27708

919-684-5245

Jessica Hardesty
Jessica.Hardesty@duke.edu

Duke University
University Program in Ecology
Department of Biology
Box 90338
Durham, NC 27708

919-680-3734